IDEALISM
Idealism is a perspective that asserts the independent
causal influence of intellectual ideas on social organization and culture.
Idealism is contrasted with materialism, which focuses on
concrete aspects of social organization as causative of particular intellectual ideas and
values.
Max Weber can be said to have given an idealistic
explanation of the growth of capitalism by linking it to the emergence of a Protestant Ethic.
Minding the world: Adorno's critique of idealism -
Espen Hammer, University of Essex, UK
Philosophy & Social Criticism, Vol. 26, No. 1, 71-92 (2000) © 2000 SAGE Publications
Against Jürgen Habermas' view that Adorno's thinking is characterized by a commitment to
a philosophy of consciousness, and that therefore the only alternative to identitarian
reason is to appeal to an intuitive competence operating beyond the range of conceptual
thought, it is arged (1) that Adorno conceptualizes the modern epistemic subject (the
subject of a philosophy of consciousness) as based on a reification, and (2) that he
denies the possibility of a concept-transcendent (foundationalist) constraint on
judgments. In seeking to demonstrate against versions of subjective idealism and
foundationalism how thought can be responsive to a non-identical (mind-independent)
reality, Adorno defends an intersubjectivist and historicist view of knowledge according
to which the operative and yet anamnetic aspiration of knowledge is to know reflectively
the object as it is in itself. The conclusion is that although Adorno questions the modern
(Kantian) stress on epistemic autonomy, he does not take leave of modernity in the sense
ascribed to him by Habermas.
Brahmanical Idealism, Anarchical Individualism, and the
Dynamics of Indian Negotiating Behavior - Rajesh Kumar, The Aarhus School of
Business, Denmark, International Journal of Cross Cultural Management, Vol. 4, No. 1,
(2004) © 2004 SAGE Publications
The article analyzes the implications of the Indian mindset on the dynamics of Indian
negotiating behavior. I argue that the constructs of Brahmanical idealism and anarchical
individualism capture the nature of the Indian mindset. Brahmanical idealism reflects the
tendency of the decision makers to seek the most perfect solution. Any discrepancies
between the realities of the external world and the logic of the inner world as manifested
through a search for the ideal solution are not problematical for it is only the inner
world that defines the true reality. If Brahmanical idealism focuses on the purity of the
mental world, anarchical individualism lays emphasis on the primacy of attaining the ideal
solution through absolutist forms of interpersonal behavior. That is to say, since each
individual is engaged in searching for the ideal solution, and furthermore, as each
individuals ideal solution is either no better or no worse than that of their
counterpart, the attainment of this ideal is problematic because under these conditions
cooperative behavior is a rarity. In this sense, anarchic individualism fragments rather
than enhances total effort, thereby draining energy away from the system. I analyze the
impact of this mindset on the Indian negotiating dynamics and outline the implications of
the framework developed here for the theory and practice of cross cultural management.
Implications for negotiating with Indian businesspeople are also discussed. -
ccm.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/4/1/39
Materialism and Idealism in Organizational Research -
Paul S. Adler, Bryan Borys, Organization Studies, Vol. 14, No. 5, (1993)
Organization theory needs a framework that can elucidate the technological, economic,
political and symbolic forces that are at work in and on organizations. Much
organizational research can be seen as materialist, by virtue of its granting primary
causal efficacy to technicaleconomic forces, or idealist by virtue of privileging
politicalsymbolic forces. The conflict between materialism and ideal ism has often
been inflated and/or obscured by conceptual strategies of specializa tion, eclecticism and
reductionism. A metatheoretical approach to materialism and idealism is presented that
clarifies the fundamental nature of the approaches and distinguishes areas of possible
reconciliation from areas of irreducible conflict.
The Conception of Wealth among the Merchants in Late
Imperial China - Weber's Idealism Revisited, Tak Sing Cheung, Tak Sing Cheung is at
the Sociology Department, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Jie Hou, Jie Hou is at the
School of History, Nankai University,
Journal of Human Values, Vol. 12, No. 1, 41-53 (2006) © 2006 SAGE Publications
This article reassesses Weber's position on the influence of Confucianism on China's
failure to develop the modern form of capitalism by focusing on the conception of wealth
among the merchants in the Ming and Qing dynasties. It starts with a review of the
criticisms directed towards Weber's theses, including his claim about an affinity between
Calvinism and the spirit of capitalism, and his assertion about the lack of moral tensions
in Confucianism. We argue that despite the flaws in his analyses, Weber's position that
ideas matter is still relevant. The main shortcoming of his argument about the link
between the Confucian value system and the failure of China to develop a modern form of
capitalism is that he overlooked a critical element in this value system. This was the
idea, widely shared among the merchants in late imperial China, of the desirability of
disposing of one's wealth. This had the effect of discouraging the accumulation of capital
in a period of incipent capitalism. While this idea was intrinsic to the Confucian
intellectual tradition, it was also reinforced by the vulnerable position of the merchants
under the omnipotent structure of state political power during the Ming dynasty. This
shows that while ideas were crucial in preventing China from developing modern capitalism,
they did not operate in isolation from the socio-political context as a historical force.
Idealism and the Sociology of Knowledge
David Bloor, Science Studies Unit, Department of Sociology, University of Edinburgh,
Social Studies of Science, Vol. 26, No. 4, 839-856 (1996) © 1996 SAGE Publications
The sociology of scientific knowledge is an empirical discipline, but occasionally it can
be fruitful to reflect on its methodological basis. Critics have sometimes claimed that it
is committed to a form of `idealism' - that is, to discounting or playing down the input
of the material world. This arises because sociologists often sum up their conclusions by
saying that `knowledge is a social institution', or that `concepts are institutions'. If
we think of social institutions according to the self-referential or performative model
outlined by Barry Barnes, this may at first seem to reinforce and justify the charge of
idealism. The main argument of this Comment is to show that while an `idealist' account of
institutions is correct, the conclusion alleged by the critics does not follow. A
secondary purpose is to compare Barnes' account of institutions with recent work by John
Searle, and to show the significance of their different underlying assumptions about the
nature of meaning. - sss.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/26/4/839
Space for Idealism? Politics and Education in the United Kingdom - Philip A.
Woods
Educational Policy, Vol. 16, No. 1, 118-138 (2002) © 2002 SAGE Publications
This article discusses the political changes that have occurred in the United Kingdom
during the past quarter century. Education as an electoral issue is placed in the context
of the political philosophies of the Conservative and Labour governments and the move from
a predominantly neo-liberalism focus to a third way approach. Some of the focal ideas and
inherent tensions and problems of the latter as developed by Labour are examined. It is
suggested that despite these, it is possible to discern in this latest phase of the long
dialogue between politicians and people the revitalization of ideals that have persisted
in an evolving tradition of political liberalism that began with 19th century British
Idealism. - epx.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/16/1/118
|