AMPLIFICATION OF DEVIANCE
Deviant Behavior, Moral Panic
Developed by Leslie Wilkens, the term 'Social
Amplification of Deviance' is used more frequently in Britain. Deviance amplification
refers to the unintended outcome of moral panics or social
policies designed to prevent or reduce deviance.
A media hype phenomenon, 'Amplification of Deviance' or
'deviancy amplification spiral' refers to an exagerated cycle of reporting on particular
antisocial behavior. The media whips up a moral panic which is coupled with calls for
strengthening the forces of law and order. In Folk Devils and Moral Panics, Stanley Cohen
wrote that moral panics usually include a deviancy amplification spiral. Certain groups
periodically become the focus of moral panics. They are labelled as being outside the
central core values of our consensual society and as posing a particular threat to them.
The groups investigated by Cohen were the Mods and Rockers. The 'central core values'
which such groups transgress against are argued to be the norms and
values which serve the interests of the dominant classes.
Typically, the attention given to deviance by the media
and moral entrepreneurs serves to attract new recruits and provides them with a definition
of what the public expects, thus amplifying the amount of deviance in society.
Because of such 'amplification of deviant behavior',
insignificant problems gain significance and uncommon events begin to look common. Media
keeps people motivated and informed on such events. The 'deviancy amplification spiral'
glamorizes and increases deviant behavior by making it acceptable.
Labeling the Labelers: A Quasi-Experiment Examining the
Deviance Amplification Hypothesis at the Organizational-Level
Ward, Jeffrey - Paper presented at the annual meeting of the AMERICAN SOCIETY OF
CRIMINOLOGY
Abstract: The two main testable hypotheses of labeling
theory, the status characteristic hypothesis and the deviance
amplification hypothesis, are derived from the conflict
perspective and the symbolic interactionist
tradition, respectively. This paper focuses on the latter hypothesis and extends the
labeling framework to the organizational-level. Symbolic interactionist labeling theorists
attempt to answer the question: what happens to the individual after being
labeled (Paternoster and Iovanni, 1989)? what happens to the organization
after being labeled? More specifically, do organizations that are labeled amplify
their deviant behavior? This paper tests the deviance amplification hypothesis at the
organizational-level using a quasi-experimental design.
African Delinquency as Social Amplification of
Deviance
Revue internationale de criminologie et de police technique Volume: 35 Issue:2
It finds labeling effects arising from inappropriately criminalized behaviors, from the
discretionary practices of arrest and prosecution authorities, and the absence of
diversion alternatives.
Cycles of Deviance: Structural Change, Moral Boundaries,
and Drug Use, 1880-1990
J E Hawdon - Journal: Sociological Spectrum Volume:16 Issue:2 Dated:(April-June 1996)
Pages:183-207
Abstract: The model tracks changes in the structure of deviance, explains when a boundary
crisis will develop, clarifies how the amplification of deviance eventually ends, and
explains how deviant behaviors sometimes become acceptable.
FORMAL PROCESSING AND FUTURE DELINQUENCY: DEVIANCE AMPLIFICATION AS SELECTION ARTIFACT
DOUGLAS A. SMITH, RAYMOND PATERNOSTER - Law & Society Review, Vol. 24, 1990
Does referring a case to juvenile court or diverting it affect a person's future
delinquent/criminal behavior? Labeling theory suggests that it does, arguing that formal
processing by the juvenile justice system is part of a deviance amplification process that
ultimately results in increased criminal/delinquent activity. But critics point out that a
higher rate of future offending among those referred to court, often interpreted as
evidence supporting the deviance amplification argument, could be nothing more than a
selection artifact. This article discusses approaches for testing the deviance
amplification argument against the alternative hypothesis of a selection artifact.
Labeling theorists ( Lemert, 1951; Becker, 1963) contend that social reactions to initial
or primary deviance may restrict one's ability to maintain a conventional lifestyle.
Limitations arise because being labeled may create barriers to legitimate employment or
lead to social censure from conventional others. This process, described by Tannenbaum as
the "dramatization of evil," increases the likelihood that the labeled person
will become more involved in and committed to a deviant line of activity than he or she
was before the labeling experience.
Religiosity and Delinquency over Time: Deviance Deterrence and Deviance Amplification. -
Peek, Charles W.; And Others
Social Science Quarterly, v66 n1 p120-31 Mar 1985
Abstract: Religiosity deters self-reported delinquent conduct in a national panel of White
high school males interviewed as sophomores, juniors, and seniors. However, decreases from
high sophomore religiosity are associated with greater senior delinquency.
The Politics of Deviance and Terror - Lauderdale, Pat
Abstract: Is the leader of loose-knit bands of hit-and-run killers of British soldiers a
terrorist? Or, is he a revolutionary hero or freedom fighter? What is your view of George
Washington? And, what is your assessment of Nat Turner who executed Virginia slave owners
and their families in 1830? Is the Jewish terrorist' in Palestine in 2003
significantly different from the Palestinian terrorist' in Israel in 2003?
How do we go about answering such questions? What conditions lead someone to be defined as
a terrorist versus a freedom fighter? The sociology of deviance also can be viewed as the
study of stratification and social mobility, rather than only the shift of moral
boundaries resulting in the amplification or creation of deviance (see Gould, 2002 on
status hierarchies). "Deviants" often struggle to overcome their positions at
the bottom of a status hierarchy, and/or others attempt to shift the balance of power
(Cummins, 1994).
Cycles of Deviance: Structural Change, Moral Boundaries, and Drug Use, 1880-1990 - J E
Hawdon
Sociological Spectrum Volume:16 Issue:2 Dated:(April-June 1996) Pages:183-207
Abstract: The model tracks changes in the structure of deviance, explains when a boundary
crisis will develop, clarifies how the amplification of deviance eventually ends, and
explains how deviant behaviors sometimes become acceptable. The historical data support
the explanation that changing moral definitions and rates of behavior depend on
demographic and economic changes in society. The two drug epidemics that occurred in the
United States since 1880 occurred when structural change expanded pluralism.
African Delinquency as Social Amplification of Deviance - G Houchon
Revue internationale de criminologie et de police technique Volume:35 Issue:2
Dated:(April-June 1982) Pages:147-164
Abstract: It proposes instead, a look at statistical and morphological aspects of the
problem and at the workings of criminal justice and child protection services. It finds
labeling effects arising from inappropriately criminalized behaviors, from the
discretionary practices of arrest and prosecution authorities, and the absence of
diversion alternatives. Particularly in the cultural milieu of African communities, judges
should not be making disposition decisions regarding status offenders and other less
serious forms of juvenile deviance.
Aggregation and amplification of marginal deviations in the social construction of
personality and maladjustment
GIAN VITTORIO Caprara, University of Rome, Italy, Philip G. Zimbardo, Stanford University,
USA
Abstract: Some social maladjustment in children is understood from a new perspective
focusing on the cyclical interaction between personality variables and social
psychological processes in the development of risk mechanisms. A profile of originally
marginal deviations between a child and peers on selected behavioural tasks and
personality functioning is a risk indicator of eventual significant perturbations in
social adjustment.
|